Debone the chicken thighs and trim off any excess meat, skin, and fat. Reserve the skin. Trim to fit the heart-shaped mold you are using (I used a heart-shaped silicone cookie sheet). Cut a V-notch on one end to help it fit nicely.
Prepare a smoker for 275 degrees F (135 degrees C).
Scrape any excess fat from the underside of the reserved skin. Reapply the skin to the chicken. Season the chicken with the rub.
Cook in the pit for about 30 minutes. This should be long enough to set the shape.
Carefully remove the chicken from the silicon mold and place it into a foil pan. Cover the foil pan tightly and cook for another 30 minutes in the pit.
Open the foil cover carefully so you don’t burn yourself with the steam escaping. Brush the heart-shaped morsels with barbecue sauce and honey. Return to the pit for 5 minutes to set. Sprinkle with hot sauce before serving.